If your lot won’t take a conventional trench bed, Ontario’s Building Code gives a designer five other ways to disperse effluent, plus a holding tank as the last resort. Which one you get depends on why the conventional bed failed: soil that drains too slowly or too fast, rock or groundwater too close to the surface, or too little room once the setbacks are drawn.
Every alternative costs more than the system it replaces. A conventional system in good soil runs $15,000 to $22,000, a raised mound $25,000 to $45,000, and a tertiary system $28,000 to $45,000 installed.
This guide compares the options at the level of the leaching bed. For the five sewage system classes, see Ontario’s septic classes explained. If a test just came back bad, start with what to do after a failed perc test.
Why a Conventional Bed Gets Ruled Out
A conventional bed is a set of absorption trenches: perforated pipe in stone, buried in native soil, fed by gravity from the tank. Under the 2024 Ontario Building Code (O. Reg. 163/24, in force 1 January 2025), it has to clear three bars.
- Soil. A percolation time between 1 and 50 minutes. Faster, and effluent reaches groundwater before the soil has treated it. Slower, and it can’t soak away.
- Depth. The bottom of each trench at least 900 mm above the high groundwater table, rock, or soil slower than 50 minutes.
- Slope and room. An average slope no steeper than 1 in 4, and space for the clearances: 15 m from a drilled well with a watertight casing at least 6 m deep, 30 m from a dug well, plus the lake, lot lines and the house.
Around the City of Kawartha Lakes the usual failures are thin soil over Shield rock in the north, heavy clay in parts of the south, a high seasonal water table on waterfront lots, and narrow lots where the setbacks leave nothing. A perc test and soil profile tell the designer which problem you have, and the answer points to a different alternative each time.
The Options at a Glance
| Option | Code section (2024 OBC) | Main problem it solves | Treatment needed | Cost to budget from |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional absorption trenches | 8.7.3 | None, the baseline | Septic tank | $15,000 to $22,000, good soil |
| Filter bed | 8.7.5 | Poor native soil, limited area | Septic tank (or better) | No separate figure; quoted from the design |
| Raised bed (fill-based trenches) | 8.7.4 | Not enough soil depth over rock or water | Septic tank | $25,000 to $45,000 (raised mound) |
| Shallow buried trench | 8.7.6 | Tight soil such as clay | Level IV unit, pressure dosed | $28,000 to $45,000 (tertiary) |
| Type A dispersal bed | 8.7.7 | Shallow rock or water, small lot | Level IV unit | $28,000 to $45,000 (tertiary) |
| Type B dispersal bed | 8.7.8 | Shallow depth, small area | Level IV unit | $28,000 to $45,000 (tertiary) |
| Class 5 holding tank | 8.8 | Nothing else is possible | None, sewage is hauled away | Install quoted per site; CKL permit $542; pump-outs $300 to $500 each |
The section numbers follow the Code’s own layout, which you can browse on CodeIndex’s Part 8 pages. The official source is the province’s Building Code page.
We have no separate range for a filter bed, so it is priced from the stamped design after a site visit. The last three bed types only exist behind a Level IV treatment unit, so the tertiary range is the one to plan around.
Filter Bed: Imported Sand Does the Treating
A filter bed swaps a long run of trenches for a compact pad of specified sand. The pipe lies in stone on top, and the sand, not the native soil, does most of the treating. The Code asks for:
- at least 750 mm of filter medium below the stone layer
- the filter medium at least 900 mm above the high groundwater table, rock, or soil slower than 50 minutes
- a base area in contact with native soil, sized from the daily flow and the soil’s percolation time
- no more than 5,000 L a day of design flow behind a plain septic tank, or 10,000 L behind a Level II, III or IV treatment unit
Designers reach for one when the native soil is too slow or too fast for trenches but there is still enough depth to rock and water. The 5,000 L cap covers most single houses; a very large one can push past it, and then the design needs a treatment unit or a different bed.
The sand is trucked in to a specification, and the Code requires the filter medium to stay unsaturated for its full depth.
Raised Bed: Building Up When You Can’t Dig Down
Most of what people call a raised bed or mound is, in Code terms, absorption trenches built in imported leaching bed fill. The fill supplies the depth the native ground is missing, so the trenches keep their 900 mm above rock or water.
The rule that surprises owners: raising a bed pushes some of its clearances outward. Certain distances from the bed must grow by twice the height it is raised above original grade, so a bed raised one metre needs two extra metres on those lines. Side slopes of the fill must stay at 1 in 4 or gentler (1 in 3 with erosion control), so the finished mound covers more ground than the pipe does. On a tight lot, that can rule out a raised bed even where the soil depth would allow one.
It suits shallow rock, a high water table or thin good soil on a lot with room to spare. No treatment unit is needed, which keeps running costs close to a conventional system’s.
A raised mound system runs $25,000 to $45,000, most of the difference being fill, trucking and machine time. Our guide to raised and mound systems covers the build and upkeep.
Shallow Buried Trench: A Clay Soil Answer
This is the least-known option, and the one the Code allows in the tightest soil. Ordinary leaching beds stop at a percolation time of 50 minutes. A shallow buried trench can go in soil up to 125 minutes, which reaches into heavy clay. The flexibility comes with equipment:
- effluent must first pass through a Level IV treatment unit
- distribution is pressurized, with at least 600 mm of pressure head at the far end of the line
- the pump chamber must hold enough to dose the effluent evenly every hour across the day
- the trench bottom still needs 900 mm above groundwater or rock
- the soil must be dry enough during construction not to smear or compact
It fits clay lots with decent depth, where a raised bed would need a lot of fill.
Budget from the tertiary range, $28,000 to $45,000 installed. There is a pump, a timer and a control panel, and the effluent pump usually lasts 7 to 10 years and costs $600 to $1,500 to replace.
Type A and Type B Dispersal Beds: Smaller Beds Behind a Tertiary Unit
Both dispersal beds sit behind a Level IV (tertiary) treatment unit. Effluent that clean asks less of the soil, so where a trench needs 900 mm to groundwater or rock, both of these need 600 mm under the stone layer.
Type A is a sand bed: at least 300 mm of specified sand, and at least 500 mm of sand and stone combined. Our post on Type A dispersal and raised sand beds explains how they get specified.
Type B is a stone bed, with stone at least 250 mm below the pipe. In soil slower than 15 minutes it can be no more than 1,000 mm deep from the bottom of the stone to finished grade, and it can’t go on ground steeper than 1 in 7, a tighter slope limit than other beds.
You see them on small waterfront lots, over shallow rock or a high water table, and in sensitive watersheds where a conventional bed can’t meet the setbacks. Septic systems for small lots explains why setbacks, not acreage, usually decide this.
The trade-off is the unit itself. It runs on power and needs an ongoing service agreement. Brands and failure points are in our guide to advanced treatment units in Ontario, and the yearly service in tertiary maintenance contracts. A tertiary system runs $28,000 to $45,000 installed, for the whole system rather than the bed alone.
Holding Tank: The Last Resort, and Not Always Available
A Class 5 holding tank has no bed: everything is stored, pumped out and hauled away. It looks like the obvious fallback, but it is not a free choice. Article 8.8.1.2 allows one only:
- for a temporary operation of up to 12 months, and seasonal recreational use does not count
- to fix an unsafe system where a Class 4 replacement is impracticable
- to upgrade a system serving an existing building, where lot size, slope or clearances rule out a Class 4
- as a stopgap until municipal sewers arrive, with the municipality committed to keeping the hauling going
The owner also signs a written agreement with a hauled sewage operator. Read plainly, none of the four grounds describes a new house on a vacant lot, so ask the City before you plan a purchase or a build around a holding tank.
The City of Kawartha Lakes Class 5 permit is $542, and the install is quoted per site. The real cost is running it: every pump-out is $300 to $500. The tank still has to sit 15 m from any well. Septic system vs holding tank covers the day-to-day differences.
How a Designer Picks Between Them
A designer usually works down this list, stopping at the first option the site allows:
- Conventional trenches, possibly in a different spot on the lot
- A filter bed, if the soil is the problem but depth is fine
- A raised bed, if depth is the problem and there is room
- A treatment unit with a shallow buried trench or a Type A or B bed, if depth, soil and space are all tight
- A holding tank, only where the Code’s grounds apply
One shortcut is worth knowing. Effluent from a Level II, III or IV unit lets a conventional trench bed be about a third shorter: the Code’s length formula drops from QT/200 to QT/300. On some lots, adding treatment without changing the bed type is enough.
The design is stamped by a licensed sewage system designer, and in the City of Kawartha Lakes it is reviewed by the City’s Building and Septic Division (705-324-9411) before a permit is issued. The standard Class 4 permit is $975 for systems up to 4,500 L a day, a designer typically charges $1,500 to $3,500, and a perc test runs $500 to $1,500. Soil testing is a late-spring-to-fall job; designers won’t test frozen ground.
Ask the designer which condition ruled out the cheaper options, whether the design needs power or a service contract, and whether your well is drilled or dug, since the well setback rules differ. For a rough number on your own lot, the replacement cost estimator uses the same ranges as this post.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest alternative to a conventional septic bed in Ontario?
It depends on why the conventional bed was ruled out. Where soil is the only problem, a filter bed is usually the least built-up option, and where depth is the problem, a raised bed avoids the cost of a treatment unit. A raised mound system runs $25,000 to $45,000, while systems built around a tertiary unit run $28,000 to $45,000 installed.
Can I get a holding tank instead of a septic bed for a new house?
Usually not. The 2024 Building Code allows a Class 5 holding tank only in listed situations, such as a temporary use of up to 12 months, fixing an unsafe system, or upgrading a system for an existing building where a Class 4 won’t fit. A new house on a vacant lot is not one of them on a plain reading, so ask the City before you rely on one.
What septic options work in clay soil?
Heavy clay is often slower than the 50-minute limit for ordinary leaching beds. A shallow buried trench can be used in soil up to 125 minutes, but it needs a Level IV treatment unit and pressure dosing. A raised bed on imported fill or a filter bed can also work, depending on how deep the clay runs and how much room the lot has.
Is a mound system the same as a raised bed?
In everyday use the two terms overlap. In the Building Code, most raised beds and mounds are fill-based absorption trenches, meaning trenches built in imported leaching bed fill. The height of the fill matters, because some clearances from the bed grow by twice the height it is raised above original grade.
Do alternative septic systems need electricity?
Some do. A filter bed or raised bed can run by gravity where the grade allows, though some need a pump to lift effluent into the bed. A shallow buried trench and the Type A and Type B dispersal beds all sit behind a Level IV treatment unit, so they rely on power and an ongoing service agreement.
Talk Through Your Lot With Us
If a designer has handed you a recommendation and you want to understand the build, call (705) 702-5526 or book a visit. The design is stamped by a licensed designer; we handle the excavation, installation and inspection booking, and every job starts with a site visit and ends with a written, itemized quote.
See septic system installation and replacement for how a job runs. Most replacements take 4 to 8 weeks from first call to finished system. We work across the City of Kawartha Lakes with no travel surcharge; for Peterborough County, Durham, the Belleville area and Haliburton, prices are quoted up front.