Kawartha Septic truck on a rural Ontario property
Emergency Guide

Rotten Egg Smell in the House: Septic, Drain, Water Heater or Gas?

If there is any chance the smell is natural gas or propane, get everyone out of the house now and call your gas utility or 911 from outside. Do not flip light switches, and do not stop to look for the

By the Kawartha Septic service team · Published

If there is any chance the smell is natural gas or propane, get everyone out of the house now and call your gas utility or 911 from outside. Do not flip light switches, and do not stop to look for the source. Both fuels are given a rotten egg odour on purpose so that a leak smells exactly like this.

Once gas is ruled out, a rotten egg smell in a rural Kawartha Lakes house almost always comes from one of five places: the water heater, the well, a dry drain trap, a blocked plumbing vent, or the septic system itself. They smell alike because most of them are the same gas, hydrogen sulphide. What separates them is where you smell it and when, so work down the list in order. Most people find the answer without calling anyone.

First, Rule Out Gas

Natural gas and propane have no smell of their own. An odorant is added so a leak can be noticed, and Natural Resources Canada describes the propane odorant as smelling “skunky” or like a rotten egg. Natural gas is treated the same way. Your nose cannot tell it from a sewer smell, so do not try.

Treat it as gas if any of these are true:

  • The house has a gas or propane furnace, water heater, stove, dryer or fireplace, and the smell is strongest near one of them
  • You hear a hiss near an appliance, a meter or the propane line
  • The smell came on suddenly and is strong through the whole house
  • Anyone feels dizzy or unwell

What to do:

  1. Get everyone out, pets included.
  2. Do not use light switches, appliances, the thermostat, the garage door opener, a lighter or a match. Anything that can spark stays off.
  3. Once you are outside and well away from the house, call the emergency number for your gas utility (it is on your bill) or your propane supplier. If you cannot reach them, call 911.
  4. Do not go back in until the utility, the supplier or the fire department tells you it is safe.

A false alarm costs you an awkward half hour. Guessing wrong about gas costs far more. If you have no gas or propane anywhere on the property, including a barbecue cylinder in an attached garage, move on to the next section.

Which One Is It? Where and When You Smell It

Where and when you smell itMost likely sourceFirst check
Near a gas appliance, or strong and sudden everywhereGas or propaneLeave the house, call from outside
Hot taps only, cold taps fineWater heater anode rodThe tap test below
Hot and cold taps both, worst after water sitsHydrogen sulphide in the well waterFill a glass and smell it away from the sink
One drain, in a room nobody usesDry trapPour water down it
Several drains, worse in wind, storms or a cold snapBlocked or frozen plumbing ventLook at the roof vent from the ground
Drains slow or gurgling, or smell outside near the tank or bedSeptic systemCheck when the tank was last pumped, then call

The tap test settles most cases. Start when no water has run for several hours; first thing in the morning is easiest. At one faucet, run the cold water and smell it. Then run the hot water and smell that. If only the hot smells, the problem is in the water heater. If both smell, it is in the water itself. If neither smells but the room still does, the source is the drains, not the water.

Hot Water Only: The Water Heater

On a well, this is a common answer, and it has nothing to do with the septic system.

Most tank water heaters contain a metal rod called an anode that corrodes on purpose so the tank does not. The Minnesota Department of Health’s page on hydrogen sulphide in well water explains that a magnesium anode can supply the electrons that help convert sulphate in the water into hydrogen sulphide gas. Warm, still water in the tank gives sulphur bacteria a comfortable home, and the smell builds up while the heater sits.

The same page lists the usual fixes:

  • Swap the anode. Replacing a magnesium anode with an aluminum one generally stops the smell. Do not simply pull the anode out: the page warns that removing it can significantly shorten the heater’s life.
  • Heat treatment. Raising the tank to 71 °C (160 °F) for several hours kills the sulphur bacteria, then the temperature goes back down. Water that hot scalds instantly, so this is a job for a plumber or for the heater’s manual, not a guess.
  • Disinfect and flush the heater with a chlorine solution.

If your water heater is a rental, call the rental company before anyone touches the anode. Either way, a pump-out will not fix this, and we would rather tell you that on the phone than bill you for it.

Hot and Cold Both: Hydrogen Sulphide in the Well

When every tap smells, hot and cold, the gas is already in the water when it comes out of the ground. Sulphur-reducing bacteria living in low-oxygen groundwater, in the well and in the plumbing, produce it naturally. It is a common feature of wells, not usually a sign that something has gone wrong.

To separate a water smell from a drain smell, fill a glass from the cold tap, walk into another room and smell the glass. If the glass smells, it is the water. If the glass is clean and the sink area stinks, it is the drain.

The smell is not a safety test. A sulphur smell says nothing about whether the water is safe to drink, and water carrying bacteria from a septic system often looks, smells and tastes normal. The only way to know is a bacteria test. Our guide on what to do when a well water test fails covers how that test works, where to get it done, and how to tell whether the septic system is involved. If the sulphur smell appeared suddenly in a well that never had it, test sooner rather than later.

Treatment has a septic cost. The usual cures for sulphur water are oxidizing filters, chlorine injection or aeration, and most filters clean themselves by flushing a large slug of water down the drain on a cycle. On most rural properties that drain goes to the septic system. Iron filter backwash into a septic system covers what that extra water does to a leaching bed and how to set a unit up so it does not drown the bed.

If you are weighing up well and septic together, the distances matter. A leaching bed must be at least 15 metres from a drilled well with a watertight casing at least 6 metres deep, and 30 metres from a dug well or any other well.

One Drain, One Room: A Dry Trap

Every drain has a trap, a bend of pipe that holds water and blocks gas coming back up from the system. Leave a drain unused long enough and the water evaporates. A basement floor drain, a guest bathroom, a laundry tub, or every drain in a cottage that sat empty all winter.

Pour water down the drain that smells and wait. If the smell fades, that was it. Drains that keep drying out need a routine: run them every few weeks. For cottages, the spring cottage opening checklist puts refilling the traps in the right order with the rest of the opening jobs.

Several Drains, Certain Weather: The Plumbing Vent

Your drains are connected to a vent pipe that runs up through the roof. It lets the gas from the system escape above the house and keeps the traps from being sucked dry when water drains. If the vent is blocked by a nest, leaves or ice, the gas takes the next way out, which is through the traps into the house.

The giveaway is timing. A vent problem shows up at several drains at once, and it tends to come and go with the weather: worse in a cold snap when frost closes the pipe, or when a storm drops the air pressure. Why a septic system smells after heavy rain goes through the weather-driven causes one by one.

Look at the vent from the ground, with binoculars if you have them. Stay off an icy or snow-covered roof. If the pipe is capped with frost or visibly packed, a plumber or roofer can clear it.

When It Really Is the Septic System

The septic system becomes the likely source when the smell comes with other symptoms:

  • Drains are slow in more than one place, or toilets gurgle when the washer empties (gurgling drains explains what the sound means)
  • The smell is outside near the tank or over the leaching bed, as well as inside
  • The ground over the tank or bed is wet or spongy without rain
  • Nobody can remember when the tank was last pumped

A tank that is overdue is the simplest version. Most households need pumping every 3 to 5 years, and the pumping schedule by household size gives the proper interval for yours. A standard pump-out for a 1,000 to 1,500 gallon tank costs $300 to $600 in the City of Kawartha Lakes.

Our guide to septic smell in the house covers the seven septic causes one by one.

One safety point matters more than any of them: never open a septic tank lid and lean over it to find out. Hydrogen sulphide is easy to smell at low levels, but Ontario’s guidance on hazardous gases notes that at higher concentrations it paralyzes the sense of smell, with loss of smell after 2 to 15 minutes at 100 ppm. The smell fading is not proof the gas has gone. Leave the tank closed and let a crew with a truck open it.

Septic smell inside the house is one of the situations we treat as urgent. Sewage backup, a screaming alarm, or septic smell inside gets same-day or next-morning response through our emergency septic service. An emergency pump-out runs $400 to $800 for a typical 1,000 to 1,500 gallon tank.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a rotten egg smell in the house dangerous?

It depends on the source, which is why gas comes first. A gas or propane leak is a fire and explosion risk, so leave the house and call from outside. A smell from the water heater or well is usually a nuisance rather than a hazard, but septic gas building up indoors is worth treating as urgent, and hydrogen sulphide at high concentrations can stop you smelling it at all.

Why does only my hot water smell like rotten eggs?

The water heater is the source. A magnesium anode rod inside the tank can react with sulphate in well water and produce hydrogen sulphide, and the warm water lets sulphur bacteria grow. Replacing the anode with an aluminum one usually fixes it, and it has nothing to do with your septic system.

Can my septic system make my well water smell like rotten eggs?

A sulphur smell in well water usually comes from bacteria in the groundwater itself, not from a septic system. Contamination from a septic system tends to show up as bacteria on a lab test, often in water that smells perfectly normal. If you are worried about the septic affecting the well, get the water tested rather than going by the smell.

Should I call the gas company or a septic company first?

The gas company, every time there is any doubt. Leave the house, call your gas utility or propane supplier from outside, and call 911 if you cannot reach them. Once they have ruled out a leak, the tap test and the drain checks will tell you whether a septic company is the next call.

Will pumping the septic tank get rid of a rotten egg smell?

Only if the tank is the source. Pumping clears an overdue tank but does nothing for a water heater anode, sulphur in the well, a dry trap or a blocked roof vent. Do the tap test and check the drains first, so you are not paying for a pump-out that leaves the smell exactly where it was.

Still Smelling It?

If you have ruled out gas, checked the taps and refilled the traps, and the smell is still there, call us at (705) 702-5526. Tell us where you smell it and when, and we can often tell on the phone whether it sounds like the septic system or something else.

For a routine pump-out you can book online; most are scheduled within 48 hours, and form requests get a call back within 24 hours during business hours. There is no travel surcharge anywhere in the City of Kawartha Lakes. In Peterborough County, Durham, Belleville and Haliburton, the price is quoted up front before the truck is booked.

Still not sure what your system needs?

Leave a number and where the property is. We will call you back with a straight answer and a real price — not a form letter.

Or call (705) 702-5526 — 24-hour emergency line.

Continue Reading